4 Truths About Screenwriting That Change After Your First Sale
What separates aspiring writers from professional ones (and how to close that gap)
Screenwriting is all about finding the right moment. The right time to write the right story and get it made. Isn’t it?
No. But I know that it can feel like that… You’re waiting.
Waiting to write your screenplay until you understand structure better. Waiting to submit until the script is perfect. Waiting to call yourself a screenwriter until someone official validates you.
Waiting until you’re ready.
And that waiting is costing you everything.
After 26 years of writing, I’ve watched two types of screenwriters. The ones who finish things and the ones who don’t. The ones who submit and the ones who keep perfecting. The ones who claim the identity and the ones who stay aspiring.
Hell, I’ve met plenty of them in the coffee shops I used to write in—even found myself being both types myself over the years.
And I used to think the difference was talent. Or connections. Or luck.
It’s neither.
The ones who move forward understand four fundamental truths that shift how you approach the entire game. And the frustrating part is that these truths don’t make sense until you’ve lived them.
But once you understand them, everything changes about how you work.
Today I’m walking you through those four truths. Whether you’ve sold something or not. Whether you’ve submitted or not. Whether you feel like a “real” screenwriter yet.
Because you don’t have to be sold to understand what separates people who make it from people who don’t.
Truth #1: The Script Matters Less Than The Person Behind It
You think if you write the perfect screenplay, it will do the work for you.
The script is so good that agents can’t ignore it. Been there. The writing is so tight that producers immediately want to develop it. Been here too. The quality speaks for itself and overrides everything else.
So you polish. You revise. You make sure every scene is essential. Every line of dialogue sings.
And you’re still not submitting because it’s not quite there yet.
But here’s what I’ve discovered actually happens in the industry… The script opens the door. The person behind the script keeps it open.
Your screenplay gets read. That’s the script doing its job. But then someone asks: Who is this writer? What’s their background? Why does this story matter to them? What else are they working on?
The script is your introduction. But you’re the ongoing relationship.
When my first TV pilot was sent to HBO on a Friday, we didn’t think we would hear anything for six months so we moved on. Yet, we heard back Monday morning and were scheduled to come in for a meeting two weeks later.
But in the meeting, what I discovered was one of the most profound lessons of my career. They had a strong idea of whether they wanted the series or not before we even came into the room. What they wanted was to hear from me, the writer, get a feel if we could work together or not for years to come.
And I got confirmation of that a couple years later when one of the exes we met with, David Levine, straight out told me how those meetings are more about me as the writer, who I am, how I see the world, and why I want to tell the story I’m trying to tell, than they are about the project.
Why? Because the script alone doesn’t carry the entire conversation.
The agents and producers and development executives want to know who you are. They want to understand your voice beyond those 60 or 110 pages. They want to know if you’re someone they’d actually want to work with for the next three years.
Your craft matters. But your perspective and values matter more.
What this means for your screenwriting
Stop writing for invisible judges who only care if your script is technically perfect.
Write understanding that real humans will read this. And they’ll want to know who you are.
Your voice. Your experience. Your specific way of seeing the world. That’s what makes the script valuable. Not the perfect formatting or the flawless structure.
The screenplay opens the conversation. Everything else is about deepening it.
Truth #2: Rejection Is Information, Not Judgment
You think rejection means your script isn’t good enough. How do I know? Because every rejection I get makes that little nasty fucker of a voice in my head confirm it for me.
I don’t know about you, but this is how it basically plays out in my head:
If your screenplay was actually good, they’d say yes.
The fact that they passed means the writing is weak.
The idea is bad.
Your voice doesn’t matter.
So you revise based on feedback you didn’t get. You rewrite scenes you thought worked. You second-guess every choice.
And you never submit again.
But rejection doesn’t mean your script is objectively bad. It means it’s not what they’re looking for right now. Or it doesn’t fit their slate. Or they already have something similar in development. Or the reader was overwhelmed and didn’t give it the attention it deserved.
Or a hundred other reasons that have nothing to do with quality.
I rewrote a script using character-driven plotting instead of plot-driven character. Same script that didn’t quarterfinalist in 25 contests. Now it’s moving past quarterfinalist in four different competitions. Not because the script suddenly got better. Because it actually became what it needed to be.
And more than just the switch of plot drivers… I stopped caring if what these characters were saying would reveal too much truth about me, or hurt people’s feelings, or have people judge me for what they’re saying. Instead, I just wrote everything these two people would say in those moments and let it live in a deep rooted truth for me.
But if I’d treated those initial rejections as verdicts on the work’s worth, I never would have revised it at all.
What this means for your screenwriting
Treat rejection as market feedback, not personal judgment.
One person passed. That’s one data point. Not the final word on whether your script is good.
Submit to multiple places. Get rejected from some. Get accepted somewhere else. Keep writing while you’re waiting to hear back.
Once you understand that rejection is just information, you can submit without fear. And you can keep submitting even after you’ve been rejected.
Truth #3: Your Skill Doesn’t Matter As Much As Your Consistency
You think if you just study screenwriting hard enough, everything will work out.
You’ll take courses. Read scripts. Practice structure. Get better and better until finally you’re good enough. Then you’ll submit and magic will happen.
So you keep studying. Keep practicing. Keep waiting until you’ve mastered the craft.
And you never actually finish a screenplay.
Because there’s always more to learn. Always another technique to understand. Always one more aspect of craft to master before you’re ready.
But the screenwriters actually moving forward aren’t the ones with the most polished craft. They’re the ones who finish things. Who submit things. Who keep writing even when they don’t feel ready.
I spent ten years thinking about writing a TV pilot. ten years imagining it. Planning what I’d do if I ever sat down.
Zero pages written.
Then I gave myself six weeks and a real deadline. I wrote it knowing it was rough. I submitted it knowing it wasn’t perfect. And that finished script matters infinitely more than ten years of planning ever would have.
And I sent it to my manager friend. Someone who has always given me the honest feedback we crave as writer’s. And someone who knows the market inside and out. And he came back with a couple of executive level notes, with feedback that told me it’s the strongest dialogue I’ve written to date (he’s always told me my dialogue is what was holding me back). And then told me if I make the few changes he suggested, it’s something we can take to market now.
A completely unexpected response to having him read it and one that proves that skill matters. But consistency matters more.
What this means for your screenwriting
Stop using craft development as an excuse for not finishing.
Finish your screenplay. It will be messy. It will have problems. Write it anyway.
Then submit it while you work on the next one. Get rejected. Get feedback. Revise while writing something new.
The produced screenwriters didn’t get there because they waited until they were perfect. They got there because they finished things. They submitted things. They kept going even after rejection.
Consistency beats perfection every single time.
Truth #4: You’re Not Aspiring Anymore Once You Act Like You’re Not
You keep saying you’re a screenwriter. But you don’t act like one.
You don’t submit. You don’t put your work in front of people. You don’t claim the identity publicly. You perform it for yourself. But you don’t own it.
So you stay in the aspiring phase. Indefinitely.
But here’s what’s strange: Everyone around you already sees you as a writer. Your friends. Your teachers. People who know your work. They don’t see you as aspiring. They see you as someone with real skills.
Take it from someone who’s lived this for years… The only person who doesn’t believe it is you.
The aspiring identity gives you an excuse to stay safe. To not submit. To not face rejection. To keep hiding behind “I’m not ready yet.”
But the moment you finish something and send it out, something shifts. You’re not aspiring anymore. You’re a screenwriter who writes and submits.
That identity changes everything about how you approach the work.
What this means for your screenwriting
Stop waiting for external permission before you claim your identity.
You’re a screenwriter the moment you finish a screenplay. Not when an agent signs you. Not when you sell something. When you write it.
And once you claim it, you start acting like it. You submit. You take feedback seriously. You revise with intention. You keep writing.
The aspiring identity is safe. But it’s also a prison.
Claim the identity first. The external validation comes after.
What Actually Changes with These Four Truths?
Understanding these four truths doesn’t transform you into a professional overnight. But it does transform how you approach the work.
You stop waiting to be perfect before you submit. You understand that the script is the beginning of the conversation, not the end of it.
You stop treating rejection like personal failure. You understand that it’s just market information. One pass doesn’t mean your script is bad.
You stop using skill development as an excuse for not finishing. You understand that consistency matters infinitely more than perfection.
You stop hiding behind the aspiring identity. You claim it. And then you act like it.
The screenwriters who move forward aren’t smarter than you. They’re not more talented. They’re not better connected.
They just understand these four truths and they actually live them.
The Bottom Line
There are four truths that separate the screenwriters who finish from the ones who don’t:
Truth #1: The script matters less than the person behind it. Your voice and perspective are what people invest in.
Truth #2: Rejection is information, not judgment. One pass doesn’t mean your script is bad.
Truth #3: Your skill doesn’t matter as much as your consistency. Finished scripts beat perfect scripts that never go anywhere.
Truth #4: You’re not aspiring anymore once you act like you’re not. Claim the identity first.
You don’t need permission to be a screenwriter. You don’t need to be sold to understand this industry. You don’t need external validation to start acting like a professional.
You just need to finish something. Submit it. And then do it again.
The aspiring phase ends the moment you decide it does.
Which of these four truths are you still resisting? What would change if you lived by them starting tomorrow?
Drop it in the comments. Let’s talk about what’s actually holding you back.
You Finished the Script. Now What?
I’m excited to share something new that’s coming to The Writer’s Table, and if you’re a screenwriter, this one is for you.
Starting this week, paid subscribers get access to The Call Sheet, a weekly submission guide built specifically for writers who are ready to stop waiting and start getting their work seen.
Every week, I pull together the film festivals, screenplay competitions, and fellowships that are actually worth your time and money. Real history on each one. My honest industry take on what a placement actually does for your career. Who it’s launched. Whether the fee makes sense for where you are right now. And so much more!
The opportunities closing that week that you need to look at today, and that you can do so over your morning cup of coffee!
You’ve got a finished script and no idea where to start? Don’t want to waste money on the wrong festivals and fellowships? FilmFreeway has thousands of festivals, and every single one of them wants your money. Some of them will change your career. Most of them won’t. Knowing the difference is the whole game, and most writers are just guessing.
The Call Sheet takes the guesswork out of it.
It drops weekly for paid subscribers only starting this week!
If you’ve been on the fence about upgrading, this is your reason.